COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF QUANTITY TAKE OFF CALCULATIONS FOR STRUCTURAL WORK USING BIM AND CONVENTIONAL METHODS

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26877/ijosbie.v7i2.1183

Keywords:

Quantity Take Off (QTO), Building Information Modeling (BIM), Autodesk Revit, Conventional Method, Pilecap

Abstract

Quantity Take Off (QTO) accuracy is essential for effective material estimation and project cost control, particularly for pilecap structures with complex reinforcement configurations. This study compares the accuracy of reinforcement and concrete quantities, as well as processing time, between Building Information Modeling (BIM) and conventional QTO methods using three categories of pilecap in the Solo-Yogyakarta-NYIA Kulon Progo Toll Road Project, Package 2.2B Trihanggo-Junction Sleman (STA 54+635 to STA 57+839). The BIM based method employed Autodesk Revit for three dimensional modeling and automatic quantity extraction, while the conventional method used AutoCAD and Microsoft Excel for manual calculations. The results revealed minimal differences in reinforcement (0.677%) and concrete volume (0.014%), indicating a very high level of agreement between both methods. However, the BIM based method required substantially longer processing time due to the additional three dimensional modeling process. These findings indicate that the primary distinction between the two methods lies in the QTO preparation process rather than the resulting material quantities. 

Author Biographies

  • Ahmad Qohhar, Universitas PGRI Semarang

    Department of Civil Engineering

  • Ir. Agung Kristiawan, S.T., M.T., Universitas PGRI Semarang

    Department of Civil Engineering

  • Ir. Lintang Enggartiasto, S.T., M.T., Universitas PGRI Semarang

    Department of Civil Engineering

  • Pramananda Nayaka Wijaya, S.T., National Cheng Kung University

    Department of Civil Engineering

References

[1] I. Wijaya and M. H. Yudhistira, “Dampak Pembangunan Jalan Tol Trans Jawa terhadap Perekonomian Daerah Kabupaten/Kota,” Jurnal Kebijakan Ekonomi, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 1–8, 2020.

[2] G. I. Sholeh, “Efektivitas dan Akurasi Metode Manual dan BIM dalam Perhitungan Volume Pile Cap dan Pembesian Bangunan Gedung,” Konstruksi: Publikasi Ilmu Teknik, Perencanaan Tata Ruang dan Teknik Sipil, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 89–101, 2025.

[3] Z. Rugas, R. Waluyo, and A. Purwantoro, “Analisis Quantity Take Off dengan Metode Building Information Modeling pada Pekerjaan Struktur Gedung Poltekkes Palangka Raya,” Jurnal Saintis, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 29–38, 2024.

[4] S. I. Amri, N. Hardyanti, and S. Sumiyati, “Analisis Perbandingan Quantity Take Off (QTO) Beton Menggunakan Metode Building Information Modelling (BIM) dan Metode Konvensional (Studi Kasus: Proyek Kantor PNM Cabang Jember),” Jurnal Profesi Insinyur Indonesia, vol. 1, no. 6, pp. 225–233, 2023.

[5] W. R. Asih, Bayzoni, H. R. Husni, and C. Niken, “Perbandingan Quantity Take Off (QTO) Material Berbasis Building Information Modeling (BIM) terhadap Metode Konvensional pada Struktur Pelat,” Jurnal Rekayasa Sipil dan Desain (JRSDD), vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 563–574, 2022.

[6] A. Maghfirona, T. I. K. Amar, and A. A. M. H. Failasufa, “Analisis Komparasi Quantity Take Off Pekerjaan Struktur Berdasarkan Metode Konvensional dan Metode BIM Studi Kasus: Perencanaan Omah DW,” Jurnal TESLINK: Teknik Sipil dan Lingkungan, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 61–67, 2023.

[7] Ramadhony, F. Y., Widyaningsih, M. K., Ikhwanudin, I., & Suwandi, P. A. P. (2026). Comparison of Cut and Fill Volume Calculation Using Building Information Modeling (BIM) and Conventional Methods (Cut and Fill Project of KIT Batang, Block A Lots 9, 10, 11, 12, and 12A). International Journal of Sustainable Building, Infrastructure and Environment (IJOSBIE), 7(1).

[8] Y. N. Dhou and A. Susanto, “Analisis Perbandingan Perhitungan Metode Konvensional dan Building Information Modelling (BIM) terhadap Volume serta Biaya Pekerjaan Konstruksi,” in Prosiding Seminar Nasional Teknik Sipil UMS, 2023.

[9] J. Pantiga and A. Soekiman, “Kajian literatur implementasi building information modeling (BIM) di Indonesia,” Rekayasa Sipil, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 104–110, 2021.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-14

Issue

Section

Articles